I am extremely picky about love stories in fiction generally: a number of common romance conventions annoy or even infuriate me (not backing off after "no" as a show of how strong someone's feelings are; love being demonstrated primarily by jealous behaviors; the cliched third act misunderstanding), either because it's so contrary to how I experience love, or because it's just bloody dysfunctional.
Queer love stories, in addition to these pitfalls, also have two common things I'm not particularly interested in reading at this point in my life: the queer awakening and coming to terms plotline, and the bigotry. We need stories that deal with both of these, and I fully encourage people to read and write them. They're just not for me - I'm not joking when I say I've been out longer than some of my subscribers have been alive. I want my stories to have queer people who exist and do awesome (and mundane) things and it's not a big deal.